Testing speakers is always a subjective experience, and I tend to find fault with computer oriented speakers, as I have spent a small fortune on my own home setup which comprises a Krell pre and power amplifier and custom Dali Grand Coupe speakers which cost as much as my last Ducati motorbike.
I always find if I go into these audio reviews with certain ‘non purist' expectations then I can arrive at a more balanced conclusion.
Firstly, after much experimentation I have to say that the Rockus 3D mode did not impress me at all when listening to music. It added sibilance and sometimes even compression related distortion to specific tracks and I found it more than distracting when trying to analyse the audio output from the Rockus 3D 2.1 speakers. For all of the audio testing, it was firmly disabled.
At low volume I found the subwoofer to be rather lacking in depth, so I decided to experiment with the bass switch and finally settled on the maximum 3 setting. Something I would normally not touch at all as increasing the bass levels beyond a certain point can colour the sound significantly. In fairness, at the higher two settings, the subwoofer delivers a very focused, punchy sound that will please those people who listen to jazz, well recorded rock and even instrumental music. At low volumes, the subwoofer has been clearly designed to not dominate the sound, but on some tracks we adjusted the equaliser in our software to compensate a little. At lower sound levels, we found the audio to be a little detached with some tracks.
Listening to 3 Doors Down ‘Away From The Sun' from their 2002 album proved an enjoyable experience. The bass lines were well reproduced and the vocals were crisp and clear, without being over sharp and fatiguing. Equally as impressive was ‘Your Decision' from Alice in Chains 2009 Album “Black Gives Way to Black'. The track exhibited very cohesive sound staging with the acoustic guitar able to cut through the rich ambient production and thumping bass lines.
At higher volumes, setting 2 was more than adequate to deliver a rollocking, balanced rhythm section. I do wish the bass control options were slightly more refined and placed on the Pod, rather than the back of the subwoofer. It proved rather inconvenient to fine tune the sound initially.
Bob Marley's classic live rendition of ‘No Woman, No Cry' was also a pleasure, with the reggae master's vocals passionately reproduced with enough impact to make me forget temporarily I was listening to speakers. Closing my eyes, I could almost feel I was in the audience. The mid range is a particular highlight with this specific design as the soundstaging always remains focused, although speaker placement is imperative in getting the most from the cones. If the speakers were too close to the subwoofer, then the soundstaging would literally fall apart.
Brandon Flowers well recorded ‘Jilted Lovers & Broken Hearts' from his Flamingo album was a clear indication that the Soundscience Rockus 3D 2.1 speakers could faithfully reproduce complex pop arrangements, able to seperate bass guitar, bass drums from multi tracked backing vocals and firmly position them within the soundstage.
MP3's are inherently prone to compression based audio distortion (even at 320kps) and to properly analyse speakers we moved to our stunning Super Audio Philips recording of The Academy of St. Martin in the Fields: Vivaldi: Guitar Concerto from 1996. The speakers truly came to life with this recording, capable of delivering a highly focused, yet impressively seperated sound field from the duelling classical guitarists.
When compared directly to the budget Arctic Cooling S361 speakers which we reviewed in January the Antec Soundscience Rockus 3D 2.1 delivered a much more dynamic experience, not suffering from the same ‘muddiness' when dealing with complex string arrangements. Concerto in A Minor for Guitar (L'estro armonico' No 6) RV356:III Presto) made the hairs on my neck stand up, and this alone deserves a mention as no computer speaker system has yet been able to do this, even the Razer Mako's which remain one of my favourites. The delicate string score complimented the subtle, beautiful acoustic passages.
There was significantly less compression during the wide open passages than experienced with the Arctic Cooling speakers, although I did notice that when pushed to their limits, they did sound a little distressed. In reality I am talking about output levels that most people wouldn't even come close to experiencing within a house. They deliver enough power to easily fill a medium sized room 15 foot by 15 foot.
Moving into a living room enviroment and when paired up with a 50 inch LCD television, the Rockus 3D functionality was finally able to deliver something worthwhile. When watching action movies, the 3D mode offered much wider soundstaging, and even if it was extremely ‘fake', it did give the impression of a few extra speakers in the room. The purist in me disliked the 3D setting outside movie based media, but other people might find it useful for ‘bigger than life' sound when trying to impress their friends.
Exceptionally well written Zardon. I like these. seem a bit above the normal, especially the design class.
Great review man. I love the appearance of the satellites. those are stunning. Might pick these up next pay day. my old creative speakers are on their last legs
Wow I must have missed the announcement that these were even released. Look good to me. bit expensive, but quality always is.
WOw I have to pick these up, the design is beautiful. sound will be more than enough for me.
Just ordered a pair, almost went for the creative gigaworks, but I know ill miss the subwoofer. these seem spot on. bit more than I wanted to pay, but ill pay the credit card later.
Hexus didnt seem to like these at all. but others seem to be extremely positive. good review. might pick them up later but id like to hear them myself 🙁
Man I love Antec, ive an antec case, antec PSU and I have to get these, when they are back in stock on newegg.
The subwoofer is quite boring looking, but those satellites are seriously sexy. very unusual design ethic. love them.
Hey, did they hire the harley davidson work force to make them ? :p
Is the sub really rated to 100W? thats very powerful for a desktop speaker system
The review text makes them sound a lot worse than 8.5 /10 tbh. It looks like an attempt to go aftr Boze and the like. The design looks nice, but it’s gimmicky and they seem way overpriced too. Corsair’s SP2500 seems to blow these out of the water from reviews i’ve seen so far.
I think the problem is Zardon is used to 10-20k systems, so he picks holes in all the areas, then realises later than they only cost £170.
Seems a fair price to me. and ive heard the corsair speakers in a local store here, wasnt that impressed, unless the setup was wrong on some level.
I don’t think the design is gimmicky at all. This shape has been proven to create very good focused sound quality, it’s a half way house to a full horn shape speaker which b@w have used before. They look really good to me and the output volume is fantastic. Tight bass is what I like
They look really different and the reviewer explained the weaknesses and strengths well. I might buy them.
Not sure they appeal to me. Design is a little over the top.
I wonder if Antec will bring more of these out, I’d like to see a 5.1 set
Pretty cool they are able to make these themselves. Its like corsair now making their own hardware.
I dont know what the dude earlier was on about the corsair ones ‘blowing these out of the water’. ive heard the corsair speakers and they sounded good, but not great. I heard this antec speakers around CES time and they sounded much better. most reviews of these speakers online are really positive. certainly the ones ive read are anyway.
Its all down to personal preference. like my buddy has a sennheiser headset he raves about and I dont have the heart to tell him they sound harsh to me. What id like he would probably thinks sucks. audio is very personal taste.
You can’t listen to speakers in a store and get any kinda sense for how they really sound. But from this review and other reviews i just get the impression they are good but not great, unlike the corsair speakers, which have generally been raved about. But it is all personal preference i guess.
the corsair speakers are so crap. i picked up a set of these and they blow the corsair ones out of the water. the corsair speakers make me think of the sound that you hear when you see an old honda civic with a 16inch such rattling the license plate driving down the street. the corsair speakers just sound cheap and loud. my friend agrees but he paid 250$ for them and can’t get rid of it. sucks for him.