Unless you yourself are a hunter who regularly kills, cleans and cooks their own meat, chances are – like most of us – you are pretty removed from the process of readying your meat for consumption. You may cook it, but few of us are actively slaughtering the animals we eat, mostly because it's more efficient, partially because we'd rather not think about it. But what about meat that was grown in a lab, rather than cut away from something living?
What about animal accessories like leather? One company, Borklyn based Modern Meadow claims it will be able to create that and more in the future. With poaching crisis like those taking place in Africa too, if animal flesh, bone and potentially horns and tusks could be grown in a petri dish, that would indeed avoid a lot of animal suffering.
However, while the idea of slaughter-less meat may appeal to some, the techniques used in its creation may not. Several years ago the company claimed it would use 3D printing to create the food, but lately it's said to be taking donor cells from unborn calves and growing them in sheets, which when combined together should create consumable meat.
Growing meat would certainly be easier for sustenance in space travel
It's this process that has some questioning the system which is often touted as having the potential to end inhumane animal treatment as part of the food production system. The problem lies with he fact that the bovine cells harvested have to be drawn from a slaughtered pregnant cow's foetus, which as the Guardian points out, often means taking blood from its heart.
When that blood is spun up in a centrifuge, you get some near perfect source cells for growing meat, but morals always get a little hazy when you're talking about unborn foetuses being used for anything. It's also very expensive; almost five times the cost of normal meat pound for pound.
It's hoped by those excited by these developments though, that the serum can soon be phased out and replaced with something more akin to a fungal serum, though whether consumers would still consider it meat remains to be seen.
Discuss on our Facebook page, HERE.
KitGuru Says: The other thing to consider with a program like this, is that the animals involved in the food industry are only alive because of their place in it. If we replace cows entirely with lab-grown food and products, what need would we have for the giant animals that consume ungodly amounts of water and plant life?
Growing meat might save one generation, but it has the potential to doom a species in the same way that horses became far less useful with the invention of the combustion engine.
Image source: Modern Meadow, Wikimedia
Yes, please, I would.
I’d be very wary of it and would probably go vegetarian if lab grown meat was the only choice. However modern farming is amazingly cruel to the animals involved and seems to keep getting worse the more industrialized it becomes, so from that perspective i’d support lab grown meat 100%.
After sufficient testing and safety checking then sure, I think people should have more moral qualms about killing more animals a year than the killing of less animals per year in a, likely, less intense and brutal process.
Though in the end, the population size of these animals would decreased and likely die out without us actively wanting them. We’ve engineered them the way we want them over thousands of years, made them dependent as well as useful and, left to their own devices, would likely die off in pretty short order without our direct input.
its an interesting take on fixing an issue that we’ll be facing not to far into the future, the truth is that as world population continues to grow we’ll be less and less able to support animal farming for meat/eggs/dairy/… its not efficient, think the 10% rule of energy conservation in the food chain; the idea that we only conserve about 10% of the energy from the food we eat to facilitate our life. take that one step further and we’re only using 1% of the original energy put into the first step in the chain; and that’s a generous estimation its likely less.
eventually it will be impossible to support the population on such diminished returns, so growing meat and dairy products will be a necessity. quibbling over something as asinine as fetal animal stem cells when we’re already killing them en mas is just stupid.
Well said Alex, some interesting figures there. Much as Chaotic Entropy mentioned, as long as the food was tested for safety before consumption then I personally wouldn’t see an issue with the idea of eating grown meat/dairy products, especially taking on board the points you mention above. Thinking about it more, I’m actually quite intrigued to try some in the future!
it has actually been done, some group produced hamburger meat a few years ago from lab grown stem cells. like the article said, its not really cost effective yet; i think the burger had a cost above $100. either way its really just an adaptation of technique that’s becoming more main stream in the medical industry, they’ve been producing structural organs (wind pipes, heart valves, bladders) for transplant for a few years now.
as for safety, well i’ve got to say a lot of peoples worries are overblown and mostly based around media hype. most of it stems from early GM corn, where a strain was produced that had a form of (i think it was a) protein that caused a severe allergic reaction in something like 1% of testers. lots of media and politicians salivated all over that story to try to support their belief that ‘playing god was wrong’ or something stupid like that.
the point i’m trying to make is that the safety of ‘genetic manipulation’, which the above referenced stem cell growth of meat isn’t really, isn’t as big an issue as the media would have you think. really i’d be more worried about the bacterial/viral issues that the current meat industry faces, or the rampant overuse of antibiotics and growth hormones to produce more product, or hell the prion scare.
the truth is that humans have NO need for ANY form of animal products. in addition to the horrific health and environmental effects which are inherent in ALL forms of animal agriculture, the moral and ethical aspects of using sentient beings as economic commodities is an atrocity of epic proportions.
there is no need to wait for lab grown flesh in order to stop supporting the violence and exploitation, one only needs to educate themselves about the truth and reality of how what and who you choose to eat got on your plate. this link will take you to a life changing one hour lecture which will go far in increasing your awareness about the issues: youtube.com/watch?v=cRc8Z8BaaFM
“If a man aspires towards a righteous life, his first act of abstinence is from injury to animals.” -Albert Einstein
Interesting vid, i’m happy to try being a vegan.. nothing to lose. Although I do work at a small dairy farm and if I ever saw cruelty like that in this guys videos, I would not be able to stop myself attacking the culprits. I do feel sorry for the animals at my work but they are at least treated properly for the duration of their time with us.
thats great that you are trying to go vegan & thanks for watching the video. while on on hand it is good that the cows on the farm you work at are not being abused as the video shows, this is not true in many cases.
as far as treating the cows “properly” so to say, that is all a matter of perspective. are their horns removed? are they branded? all of the cows who give milk are artificially inseminated (i.e. raped) once a year and their babies are taken from them as soon as they are born-with the males going for veal and the females back into the dairy industry where their lives consist of eating, sleeping and being forcibly milked at a rate of many times more than is natural for them. finally, as the video states after 5-6 years of this (with cows living anywhere from 18-25 years) they can no longer produce enough milk to cover their costs they are sold to slaughter to be made into pet food & cheap ground meat.
the bottom line is that depsite how one perceives them to be treated, in animal agriculture they exist only as machines with all of their interests and natural instincts suppressed and have only a brutal murder after a very short life span awaiting them. here are a few other documentaries you may be interested in and which may give you more insight:
peaceablekingdomfilm.org/
cowspiracy.com/
Which is precisely why I still feel sorry for our cows. Our cows do have there horns removed and are inseminated, they only see there calves for 3-4 days after birth and get milked twice a day. All of the above is bad but in comparison to the larger, more industrialised farms our cows do pretty well in comparison. Our cows also get a couple months ‘holiday’ once a year when they run dry, they are inseminated during this time I believe, and then return to the main herd.. eventually though they do end up at the local butchers 🙁
Don’t get me wrong, I do believe the whole livestock industry is sick and I have put my name to many a petition. I don’t understand how people can be so cruel either, I milk 55 cows morning and evening and each one has it’s own personality, which after working with them for a few weeks most people would begin to see. So how those farmers in the guys last video could knowingly be so evil is beyond me.
Health issues aside I think the main reason people are against GM food is that it can be patented and sold cheap while the natural breedsvarieties die off, afterwards this basically leaves the market for the GM product only. Monsanto has already tried getting the ball rolling with this, farmers are not allowed to harvest any seed from monsanto’s corn for replanting the following year and the ground is so saturated with monsanto’s chemicals that natural varieties of corn won’t grow.
it is a question of use and not one of treatment. some forms of violence and exploitation are worse than others, but none of it is morally justifiable-especially since it is done in the name of pleasure and profit. if i were to murder someone in order to take what i wished from them, it would be better not to torture them before hand but that in no way makes the fact that you are killing them any better.
i think to be morally consistent, it is imperative to follow the Golden Rule-if you would not wish something forced upon you, it is not ethical to force it upon others. since no one would like to be considered mere property and treated how the cows you work with are (i.e. mutilated, raped and brutally murdered at a very young age), how then is it right to do this to sentient non-human animals?
drinking the milk of another species, especially as an adult, is anything but natural or necessary and humans have no need of cows milk any more than we need the milk of any other animal-aside from human mothers milk as an infant. if one can live without intentionally harming others, why would anyone choose not to?
i would.
my mate’s mother makes $98 consistently on the PC………After earning an average of 19952 Dollars monthly,I’m finally getting 98 Dollars an hour,just working 4-5 hours daily online….It’s time to take some action and you can join it too.It is simple,dedicated and easy way to get rich.Three weeks from now you will wishyou have started today – I promise!….HERE I STARTED-TAKE A LOOK AT…..ifk..
➤➤➤➤ https://googlehighvaultconfirmedjobshubonline/earn/$98/hour…. ⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛⚛