Closing Thoughts
Before we started testing for this review we deliberately tempered our hopes. After all, we are effectively dealing with the P-cores from seven 12th Gen Core i7 or Core i9 CPUs in a very large package, and that sounds like a very curious combination. Even so, we were shocked to see a CPU power draw of 495W at a mere 2.9GHz and this is especially true when you consider the W-3400 family of CPUs are officially rated at 350W.
Our takeaway is that 4th Gen Xeon can easily run at higher clock speeds, however the brutal power draw is a major limitation. We have to hope the Emerald Rapids update will move things in the correct direction and after that Granite Rapids on the Intel 4 process should make further progress on power efficiency. The obvious point is that AMD is a moving target and Intel has an obligation to hit its targets and deliver on its promises.
Pros:
- Impressive performance from the high core count models.
- The price is competitive with AMD.
- CPU temperatures are icy cold.
Cons:
- Clock speeds are held back by the high power draw.
- The power draw is far too high compared to AMD.
- Sapphire Rapids has suffered delay after delay.
KitGuru says: Intel has returned to HEDT but we need improvements from their 5th Gen technology later this year.